The 7 Best Casserole Dishes

Ready to whip up cozy and satisfying casseroles? Try one of the top-notch casserole dishes in our guide. 

Blair loves coming up with easy dump-and-bake dinners, and to do so, you’ll need a great casserole dish for even temperature and effortless cooking. To narrow down the best choices, Blair and I researched the top sellers, looking for features like ergonomic handles and broiler-safe materials. While Blair swears by products from Dansk, Staub, and Le Creuset, we found other great casserole dishes to stock in your kitchen as well. 

Our Top Picks: 

1. What’s in Blair’s Kitchen: Staub Ceramic Rectangular Baking Dish (13×9) – $79.95 at Amazon
2. Blair’s Other Favorite: Dansk Kobenstyle Baker (13×9.75) – $135 at Food52
3. Best with Lid: Le Creuset Stoneware Heritage Covered Rectangular Casserole (12×9 – $134.95 at Amazon
4. Best for Lasagna: Rachael Ray Rectangular Stoneware Baker (9×13) – $39.95 at Amazon
5. Best Glass: Pyrex Easy Grab Glass Rectangular Baking Dish with Lid (9×13) – $14.99 at Target
6. Best Large: Corningware French White Four Quart Oval Ceramic Casserole Dish with Glass Cover (9×15) – $69.99 at Amazon
7. Best Small: OXO Good Grips Glass Two-Quart Baking Dish with Lid (9.4×10.6) – $17.99 at Amazon

Reviews of The Best Casserole Dishes

1. What’s in Blair’s Kitchen: Staub Ceramic Rectangular Baking Dish 

It’s no wonder that Blair uses this for practically all of her casseroles. She loves the brand so much that she owns several bakers. “I like this casserole dish’s sturdy construction,” she says. “I have Staub ceramic bakers in a variety of shapes and sizes, some with lids and some without. They’re deep, easy to clean, and very durable!”

This rectangular ceramic baking dish is the complete package: functional and stylish. Safe for the freezer and broiler, it retains heat well and features a scratch-resistant finish. Plus, thanks to its large handles, the baking dish is easy to pull out of the oven and carry. Like Blair, we agree that the Staub is stunning to look at, which makes it good to move from oven to table, for everything from casual to formal occasions. Blair also boasts how well-made this dish is, and from her experience, it should last you for years.

The Specs:

• Rectangular white ceramic baking dish
• Weighs four pounds
• 13 inches by 9 inches
• Safe for the microwave, freezer, oven, and broiler up to 572 degrees F

The Pros:

• Transitions perfectly from oven to table
• Scratch-resistant finish
• Retains heat well

The Cons:

• Heavy
• Although dishwasher-safe, hand-washing recommended
• No lid

What Others are Saying:

Serious Eats applauds this casserole dish for its form and function, and Good Housekeeping deems it the “best high-end casserole dish.”

Buy the Staub Ceramic Rectangular Baking Dish: 

2. Blair’s Other Favorite: Dansk Kobenstyle Baker 

Aside from the Staub, Blair relies on this stylish, durable casserole dish from Dansk on a regular basis. It’s a bit lighter than ceramic casserole dishes and offers some mid-century Scandinavian flair thanks to the minimalist handles. Blair loves the design so much that she owns it in both the midnight blue and white colors. 

Since it’s safe up to 572 degrees F, Blair says she can stick it under the broiler for crisp, brown toppings. The carbon steel construction and handles mean that it can heat food evenly, and it’s lightweight enough to hold and manage easily. What impressed Blair the most about this casserole dish is how easy it is to clean. “The food just wipes right off,” she says.

The Specs:

• Enamel-coated carbon steel
• Comes in multiple colors
• 13 inches by 9.75 inches
• Safe for the freezer, stove, and oven (up to 572 degrees F)

The Pros:

• Scandinavian design that’s stylish enough for the table
• Easy to clean
• Fairly lightweight
• Handles for easy holding

The Cons:

• Pricey
• No lid
• Not available from multiple retailers
• Hand-wash only

What Others are Saying:

This product is an undiscovered gem in the United States, which Blairs thinks should be better appreciated for its beauty, quality, and versatility.

Buy the Dansk Kobenstyle Baker: 

3. Best with Lid: Le Creuset Stoneware Heritage Covered Rectangular Casserole

The fan-favorite Le Creuset offers a casserole dish that features a lid, so you can keep dishes warm once they leave the oven. Excellent at distributing and retaining heat, this ceramic dish features an interior enamel nonstick finish for easy clean-up. Plus, it’s durable, thermal-resistant, and safe for the freezer, broiler, and dishwasher. A gorgeous addition to your table, it comes in more than a dozen colors, and you might want to consider stocking up on a few of these heirloom pieces.

The Specs:

• Lidded
• 4-quart
• 12 inches by 9 inches
• Thermal-resistant from temperatures between -9 and 500 degrees F
• Safe for freezer, microwave, oven, broiler, dishwasher, and metal utensils

The Pros:

• Perfect for oven-to-table
• Heirloom piece 
• Interior enamel nonstick finish

The Cons:

• Pricey
• Heavy (8.6 pounds)

What Others are Saying:

Both The Spruce Eats and Good Housekeeping recommended this product, with GH voting it the best lidded casserole dish. Additionally, there are nearly 1,000 Amazon reviews with an average rating of 4.7 stars.

Buy the Le Creuset Stoneware Heritage Covered Rectangular Casserole: 

4. Best for Lasagna: Rachael Ray Rectangular Stoneware Baker

With wide handles for comfortable holding and a casual design, this is a solid pick for everyday cooking. Large and deep, this dish is ideal for lasagnas and hearty casseroles. After using it for cozy family get-togethers, you can just throw it in the dishwasher for no-fuss cleaning. Since this stoneware casserole dish is freezer-safe and budget-friendly, you can buy several to prep a couple of casseroles ahead of time and store them for later.

The Specs:

• 4.5-quart capacity
• Rectangular glazed ceramic
• Microwave, freezer, and oven-safe to 500 degrees F
• Dishwasher-safe

The Pros:

• Inexpensive
• Deep enough for lasagna
• Easy to clean
• Wide handles

The Cons:

• No lid
• Contemporary look won’t go with all home styles

What Others are Saying:

The Spruce Eats and Good Housekeeping both praised this product—GH liked its versatility and large ergonomic handles. With more than 1,100 Amazon reviews, it has an average rating of 4.7 stars.

Buy the Rachael Ray Rectangular Stoneware Baker: 

5. Best Glass: Pyrex Easy Grab Glass Rectangular Baking Dish with Lid

You can’t go wrong with a glass casserole dish from this reliable glassware company. It’s safe for the freezer, dishwasher, microwave, and preheated oven and isn’t too hard on your wallet. The glass material makes it lightweight, and resistant to stains and odors. Plus, thanks to its handles, it’s easy to hold and carry. Even better: the included plastic lid makes it ideal for bringing to potlucks. 

The Specs:

• 3-quart 9 inches by 13 inches glass baking dish with lid
• BPA-free tempered glass
• Handles
• 4.66 pounds

The Pros:

• Safe for the freezer, microwave, preheated oven, and dishwasher
• Budget-friendly
• Resists stains and odors
• Easy to hold

The Cons:

• Not as beautiful or stylish
• Not an heirloom piece

What Others are Saying:

Awarded “best budget” casserole dish by Good Housekeeping, this product was rated an average of 4.7 stars by 216 Wayfair shoppers.

Buy the Pyrex Easy Grab Glass Rectangular Baking Dish with Lid: 

6. Best Large: Corningware French White Four-Quart Oval Ceramic Casserole Dish with Glass Cover

Elegant and white with fluted sides, this oval casserole dish lends itself well to fancier meals. With its four-quart capacity, it will hold enough food for holiday get-togethers—which its lid will help keep warm. Because of its handles and relatively lightweight glass-ceramic construction, it’s easy to hold and carry. As an added plus, it’s practical: It’s safe for the microwave, broiler, freezer, and dishwasher. We can already picture the green bean casserole on the Thanksgiving table.

The Specs:

• 4 quarts
• 14-3/4 inches long, 6-1/2 inches high with lid
• Solid handles
• Safe for the microwave, broiler, freezer, and dishwasher

The Pros:

• Easy to lift
• Deep enough for braised dishes
• 10 year warranty against breakage due to thermal shock
• Easy to clean

The Cons:

• Only comes in one color
• Not as beautiful or an heirloom piece

What Others are Saying:

This traditional looking dish has an average of 4.6 stars from more than 509 Amazon reviews.

Buy the Corningware French White Four-Quart Oval Ceramic Casserole Dish with Glass Cover: 

7. Best Small: OXO Good Grips Glass Two-Quart Baking Dish with Lid

For making smaller portions or batches of casseroles to share, you’ll definitely want to stock up on a two-quart casserole dish like this one. It’s safe for the microwave, dishwasher, oven, and freezer making it a versatile and practical option. Plus, the glass material is especially easy to clean. This affordable OXO dish has the brand’s classic comfortable grip, and it’s also lightweight, making it a breeze to pull out of the oven and carry. 

The Specs:

• Two-quart
• Made of BPA-free borosilicate glass
• Handles
• 10.6 inches by 9.4 inches

The Pros:

• Easy to clean
• Inexpensive
• Lightweight, at 3.1 pounds
• Safe for microwave, dishwasher, oven, and freezer

The Cons:

• Not the most aesthetic
• Not broiler-safe

What Others are Saying:

It has an average of 4.8 stars from nearly 15,000 reviews on Amazon.

Buy the OXO Good Grips Glass Two-Quart Baking Dish with Lid: 

Other Casserole Dishes We Considered

Emile Henry Rectangular Baker-Modern Classics Collection

For a traditional-looking casserole dish that’s fit for Christmas dinner, reviewers find themselves reaching for this one by Emily Henry. This elegant rectangular ceramic casserole dish is safe for the freezer, oven, microwave, and dishwasher. Although, its handles are not that easy to grab. The Emile Henry Rectangular Baker-Modern Classics Collection is available for $78.29 on Amazon.

Anchor Hocking Three-Quart Glass Baking Dish

Large capacity and easy to clean, this is another solid bet among glass casserole dish options. However, it’s a bit pricier than similar products and it comes with a plastic lid that is not oven-safe, so you may be better off with one of the choices above. The Anchor Hocking Three-Quart Glass Baking Dish is available for $26.99 on Amazon.

Lodge Enameled Cast Iron Covered Casserole, 3.6-Quart

Lodge is known for its cast iron products, creating a beautiful and heavy duty cast iron casserole dish with an included lid. At 14.61 pounds, it’s the heaviest among the options and should be hand-washed. The Lodge Enameled Cast Iron Covered Casserole, 3.6-Quart is available for $135.38 on Amazon.

Why You Can Trust Us

I’m Dina, a lifestyle writer, author of six cookbooks, and lover of casseroles, especially baked pasta. I worked on this roundup of the best casserole dishes with Blair, the voice behind The Seasoned Mom, who has developed dozens of casseroles and dump and bake recipes using her beloved casserole dishes to do so.

To come up with our list of the best casserole dishes, we tapped Blair to find the ones she owns and loves to use for her recipe photos. Then we browsed the most popular casserole dishes on the market, researched other buying guides from cooking experts and trusted review sites, and determined other great options that Blair hasn’t had the opportunity to try yet. After comparing the specifications and prices to one another, we came up with our list of the best casserole dishes.

Everything to Know Before Buying a Casserole Dish

What is a Casserole Dish, Exactly?

A casserole dish is a large deep cooking vessel used for oven cooking. You can use it to create delicious lasagna, bread pudding, and all types of sweet and savory casseroles.

What to Consider When Shopping for a Casserole Dish

• Blair recommends casserole dishes in a variety of shapes and sizes so you have the right bakeware for different uses and yields. The most popular sizes are 9 inches by 13 inches and 8 inches by 8 inches. 
• Look for handles for safe and easy transport in and out of the oven; as well as a sturdy material, such as ceramic or carbon steel, to prevent shattering. 
• An interior enamel coating, which wipes clean and doesn’t require hours of soaking and scrubbing after baking, makes cleanup easy as well.

Can You Put a Casserole Dish in an Air Fryer?

Yes, you can use oven-proof casserole dishes in an air fryer. However, you’ll need a smaller sized casserole dish that would fit into the dimensions of the small appliance.

Can You Use a Dutch Oven as a Casserole Dish?

Yes, you can use a Dutch oven as a casserole dish. Just be aware that because Dutch ovens are usually deeper than casserole dishes, you might need to adapt your recipe and the cooking time.

The Best Casserole Dish Recipes

If you need some inspiration to put your new casserole dishes to the test, The Seasoned Mom has a plethora of fan-favorite recipes. Here are some of the most popular ones:

• Dump and Bake Meatball Casserole 
• Southern Squash Casserole
• Tuna Noodle Casserole
• Dump and Bake Chicken Alfredo Pasta Casserole
• Garlic Parmesan Zucchini Casserole
• King Ranch Chicken Casserole
• Chicken and Stuffing Casserole

Prices and ratings were accurate at time of publication.